Write a discussion essay with the title Film first or book first? Discuss.

1. Introduce the topic. 

2. Why is it better to read the book first? Present the arguments.

3. Why is it better to watch the film first? Present the arguments.

4. In your opinion, which is better: watching the film first or reading the book first?

Paragraph 1: Most people... But is it better to ...?

Paragraph 2: On the one hand, ...

Paragraph 3: On the other hand, ...

Paragraph 4: All things considered, ...

Sample 1:

Nowadays, most people either read a book or watch a movie in their free time, for entertainment purposes. Printed books and movies have some similarities and differences. Some people argue that books are better than movies and vice versa. However, this is a controversial issue that has been discussed a lot recently.

On the one hand, imagination plays a very important role when we speak of books and movies. Reading allows us to imagine the situation, environment, characters and their personality. Basically, movies are made from our imagination. Studies show that reading does improve a person’s creativity due to imagination: because you are using your brain while reading, your concentration and focus levels improve. On the other hand, movies leave viewers with little imagination, but they focus on visual effects.

However, movies take at most 4 hours of your time, such as the movie “Lord of the Rings 3”, but the average length of a movie is between 1.5 to 2 hours. A lot of people would rather watch a movie than read a book, claiming that it is not worth spending effort and time as you can watch the movie without requiring much effort from your side.

A final point to share is that even though books and movies are different entities, they have some similarities. For instance: the ideas of both topics share the same main idea. Also, both books and movies are considered as sources of media, as they are both sources of knowledge and are used for entertainment purposes. However, they differ in some ways. For example: Books, as we all know, tend toward focusing on details while movies cut out the over-detailed parts so that the viewer doesn’t feel bored while watching the movie. In addition, movies are considered as visual media while books are typographic media.

In conclusion, we can’t conclude which media is better because this all depends on the individuals’ choice, personality and even age. Older people read books more than they watch movies, while the youth would rather watch a movie at their recreation time. Movies and Books have different ways of presenting the story. However, they provide some similar prospects such as main ideas.

Sample 2:

Most people enjoy both books and movies as forms of entertainment. Many popular films are adaptations of well-loved books, sparking a common debate: is it better to read the book first or watch the film first?

On the one hand, reading the book first has several advantages. Books often contain more detailed plots, deeper character development, and richer world-building than their film adaptations. By reading the book first, one can fully immerse themselves in the author's original vision and understand the subtleties that might be lost in the film. Additionally, reading the book first allows for a more personal interpretation of the story, as one's imagination creates unique images and feelings that are not influenced by the film's portrayal. This can lead to a more profound and personalized experience.

On the other hand, watching the film first can also be beneficial. Films are more accessible and less time-consuming than books, providing a quick and engaging introduction to the story. For those who struggle with reading or have limited time, watching the film can spark interest in the book and make the reading experience more enjoyable by providing a visual and emotional context. Moreover, watching the film first can prevent disappointment from unmet expectations, as viewers will not have preconceived notions about how the story should unfold, allowing them to appreciate the film on its own terms.

All things considered, whether it is better to watch the film first or read the book first depends on individual preferences and circumstances. In my opinion, reading the book first is generally better because it allows for a deeper and more personal connection to the story. However, watching the film first can be a great way to get a quick overview and generate interest in the book, especially for those with limited time or different learning preferences. Ultimately, both approaches have their merits, and the best choice varies from person to person.

Sample 3:

Lots of people wonder whether it's better to read the book before watching the movie or the other way around. Let's talk about the pros and cons of each.

On the one hand, reading the book first has its perks. Books usually have more details and deeper stories than movies. When you read the book first, you get to imagine the characters and scenes in your own way. Plus, you can really connect with the story and characters on a personal level. Also, you get to understand the author's original ideas better.

But on the other hand, there are good reasons to watch the movie first. Movies are often easier to access and understand than books. They give you a quick taste of the story and can make you curious about the book. Watching the movie first lets you enjoy the director's take on the story without any expectations from the book.

So, whether you choose to read the book or watch the movie first depends on what you like. Some people prefer reading first to dive deep into the story, while others like watching the movie for a quick introduction. Personally, I think it's up to you! Both ways have their own fun and can help you enjoy the story in different ways.

Sample 4:

Most people enjoy experiencing stories through both books and films. But is it better to read the book first or watch the film first? This question has been debated by many book lovers and movie enthusiasts. Each approach has its own advantages and drawbacks, and deciding which is better depends on what you want to gain from the experience.

On the one hand, reading the book first has several benefits. Books often provide more detailed backgrounds, character development, and intricate plot lines that films might condense or overlook. Reading the book allows you to create your own interpretations and imaginations of the story's world and characters without being influenced by the film's visual representation. Additionally, books can delve deeper into the characters' thoughts and emotions, offering a richer and more immersive experience. By reading the book first, you can appreciate the full depth of the author's original vision.

On the other hand, watching the film first can also be advantageous. Films provide a visual and auditory experience that can make the story more accessible and engaging, especially for those who might find reading challenging or time-consuming. Watching the film first can serve as a gateway to the book, sparking interest in readers who want to explore the story further. Additionally, films can enhance the story with special effects, music, and performances by actors, which can bring the characters and scenes to life in a way that might enhance your enjoyment of the book later on.

All things considered, whether it is better to watch the film first or read the book first depends on personal preferences and what you seek from the story. If you prefer a detailed and imaginative experience, reading the book first might be the best choice. However, if you enjoy visual storytelling and want a quick introduction to the plot, watching the film first could be more suitable. In my opinion, reading the book first is better because it allows for a deeper understanding and appreciation of the story, which can then be enriched by the film adaptation.

Sample 5:

Most people love enjoying stories through books and movies. But is it better to read the book first or watch the film first? This is a question many book lovers and movie fans often discuss. Each choice has its own benefits and drawbacks, and deciding which is better depends on what you want from the experience.

On the one hand, reading the book first has several good points. Books often give more detailed stories and background that films might not show because of time limits. By reading the book first, you can understand the full story, including side plots and character details that might be left out of the film. This way, you can imagine the characters and settings in your own way. Also, books can build suspense and develop the plot more slowly and deeply.

On the other hand, watching the film first can also be helpful. Films can make complicated stories easier to understand by shortening and simplifying the plot, which can be good for those who find long texts hard to read. Watching the film first gives you a clear and simple idea of the story, making the book easier to follow and enjoy later. Plus, films can create strong emotional responses with their visuals and music, making you connect with the story and characters quickly.

All things considered, whether it is better to watch the film first or read the book first depends on personal taste and what you want from the story. If you like detailed and imaginative experiences, reading the book first might be the best choice. However, if you enjoy visual storytelling and want a quick overview of the plot, watching the film first could be better. In my opinion, reading the book first is better because it gives a deeper understanding and appreciation of the story, which the film can then enhance.